The Pros and Cons of Vinyl Siding


The homeowner considering residing a home is faced with more than half a dozen choices as to the material that should be used.  The decision that the homeowner ultimately makes is an important one because a home is probably the biggest investment a person makes, and the choice of a siding which will protect that home that investment is one of the most important decisions that a homeowner is faced with.

This article does not attempt to sell the homeowner any particular type of home siding.  The purpose of this article is merely to provide the homeowner with as much unbiased information as possible about one particular type of siding vinyl siding so that the homeowner can include this information when making an informed decision.  So here are vinyl siding pros and cons.

Vinyl siding has made huge strides in just the past few years.  Many old notions of vinyl must be discarded and the cedarimpressions-resized-600homeowner needs to come to this discussion with an uncluttered perspective.  From an aesthetics standpoint, today’s vinyl mimics the look of real wood much more realistically than the faux-wood vinyl panels of just a few years ago.  One of the reasons some people disliked the vinyl panels of even ten years ago was the fact that the panels had a seam in them that destroyed the illusion that they might be wood.  Today’s vinyl has no seams and the texture of the panels looks more like wood than ever.

The true key to vinyl is the thickness of the siding.  Many homeowners are unaware that vinyl comes in at least three gauges or thicknesses, or that the gauge of the siding they choose determines how long their siding will last.  Obviously, the thicker the vinyl is, the thicker the gauge and the more the siding will cost.

The vinyl sold in many home centers is 40 to 45 gauge size.  This is adequate and can last 25 years or more in many climates.  However, for the homeowner who wants true durability and a siding that can last 40 years or more with little or no maintenance, a 55-gauge (.55 inch thick) siding is recommended.

Vinyl panels generally come fully painted, with the color infused with the vinyl itself so it cannot flake or chip off.  Homeowners can choose from a wide palette of colors, matching almost any color scheme the homeowner can come up with.  If just the right shade is not available in a pre-colored vinyl panel, vinyl siding can be painted any color that the homeowner chooses.

One of the primary reasons that vinyl has become “king” in the house siding world is that once the vinyl is installed, there is virtually no maintenance to perform for the next 30 or 40 years.

That is not to say that a vinyl panel attached to a home today will look just as good 40 years from now as it does now it will not, but if a homeowner does nothing to a 55-gauge panel for forty years, it could still do its job of keeping the home dry and safe in many climates.  And that is something.

Of course, to keep a home’s vinyl siding looking good and relatively new, the siding will need to be washed at least vinyl-blogphoto01-resized-600once per year and painted every eight to 10 years.  Under the glare of the sun, the colors infused into vinyl panels do fade with time, so without a certain amount of care, such as occasionally repainting, vinyl siding does tend to look old after a few years.

Another point to keep in mind is cost.  Vinyl is one of the least expensive sidings a homeowner can buy.  Not only are the initial costs less than virtually any other siding, but the installation is also fast and inexpensive as well due to vinyl’s lightweight and interlocking design.

Vinyl does have its drawbacks, however, and homeowners need to be aware of them.  For one thing, vinyl dents rather easily, even the heavier gauges.  An errant baseball, hail, or even a power wash can dent vinyl, and very often the dents do not pop back out no matter what the homeowner does.

If a panel is dented or needs to be replaced for any other reason, it can be extremely difficult, time-consuming and expensive.  Vinyl panels overlap, and because they are attached in an interlocking pattern, they can be extremely difficult to remove and it can be almost impossible to insert a new piece of siding.

Not only that but matching the color of an existing panel with a new panel can be virtually impossible unless the damaged panel is almost new.  The reason for this is that the colors permeated into vinyl panels fade over time, making a newly inserted panel stand out.  Also, it can happen that a manufacturer will cease manufacturing a certain color of panel, making it impossible to color-match an older piece of vinyl.

Cold can also be a vinyl killer.  In extremely cold weather, vinyl can become brittle and crack under the least provocation.  Cracks in the siding allow water to seep behind the vinyl and that can cause incalculable damage to the framing of a home.

There can be another problem with cold weather: vinyl does not insulate well.  This problem can be alleviated, at vinyl-blogphoto02-resized-600least to a large degree, by either wrapping the home with an insulating house wrap or putting heavy-duty insulation into each wall cavity before the vinyl is applied.  There is a thin insulating material that can be placed under the vinyl itself, but this does little in the way of actually insulating a home against either cold or heat.  The cost of additional insulation must be calculated into the total price of vinyl siding when making siding comparisons.

In extreme heat temperatures, vinyl siding can also melt and cause severe problems in locations where irregular weather patterns are the norm.

To sum up, the main advantages of vinyl are its low cost and ease of installation combined with its low maintenance.  Some homeowners are also pleased with the way modern vinyl panels look.  Drawbacks include being easily dented, the difficulty of replacing individual panels, color fading and potential cracking in extremely cold weather.  All of these factors must be weighed carefully against the pros and cons of other types of siding when making a decision as important as installing new siding on a home.

5 replies
  1. Troy Blackburn
    Troy Blackburn says:

    I wasn’t aware that the true key, like you mentioned, to vinyl siding is the thickness. That’s interesting that it comes in three different thicknesses. I’ve heard that vinyl siding can help keep the heat in your home almost as if it’s another layer of insulation. With winter upon us, I’m deciding if it’s worth switching to vinyl or not and this article will help me lots in deciding. Thank you!

  2. Afton Jackson
    Afton Jackson says:

    I didn’t realize that vinyl siding can go 30 or 40 years without hardly any maintenance. My sister just moved into a used home. Hopefully, she can use this info to choose a siding that gives her care-free style.

  3. Kylie Dotts
    Kylie Dotts says:

    I like how you said that today’s vinyl siding matches the look of real wood. We’re going to be renovating our patio area this year and are thinking about doing an extension on our dining room as well. We would love to get that warm feeling of wood siding so maybe we’ll have to look into replacing our old one with some good vinyl that could help us get the look we’re hoping for.

  4. United Home Experts
    United Home Experts says:

    Thanks for reading Kylie! If you’re interested in finding a siding solution that looks like wood without the maintenance, we recommend checking out a composite siding. Let us know if we can provide any information to you.

  5. Ridley Fitzgerald
    Ridley Fitzgerald says:

    Vinyl siding sounds like a pretty great option! Washing it once a year isn’t a big deal at all. We’re looking to remodel the exterior of our house, and putting vinyl up seems like the thing to do.

Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *