Sherwin Williams vs Olympic Paint:

It’s been over a decade since United Home Experts first published our Sherwin Williams vs Olympic Paint comparison in 2014. Today, we’re revisiting this popular topic with a fully updated 2025 review. Based on thousands of painting projects across Eastern New England, we’ve compiled new insights to help homeowners choose the best paint brand for their homes.

Overall Scores:
Sherwin Williams: 94 / 100
Olympic Paint: 82 / 100

These scores are based on five key categories: VOC content, self-priming performance, moisture resistance, durability, and warranty support. Below, you’ll find a detailed breakdown of each category based on product availability as of 2025.

Volatile Organic Compound (VOC) Content

Both brands offer low-VOC and zero-VOC options. However, Sherwin Williams provides a wider range of zero-VOC paints, including popular lines like Emerald, Harmony, and SuperPaint. Olympic offers some low-VOC and zero-VOC products, but the selection is limited mostly to their premium interior options.

Score: Sherwin Williams: 95 / Olympic: 85

Self-Priming Performance

Sherwin Williams offers several self-priming paints, including SuperPaint and Emerald, which allow for strong adhesion and coverage without a separate primer. Olympic does offer self-priming options, but most require a separate primer to achieve full coverage and durability.

Score: Sherwin Williams: 92 / Olympic: 80

Moisture Resistance

Sherwin Williams’ Resilience paint stands out for its fast-drying, moisture-resistant properties. It can resist rain just two hours after application, which is a major advantage in New England’s unpredictable weather. Olympic does not offer an equivalent product with the same level of moisture defense.

Score: Sherwin Williams: 97 / Olympic: 78

Durability and Finish Quality

Sherwin Williams paints tend to apply thicker, requiring fewer coats. Products like Duration and Emerald are known for their long-lasting results and superior surface adhesion. Olympic’s paint lines have improved over the years but still fall slightly short in longevity and finish consistency when applied to high-exposure surfaces.

Score: Sherwin Williams: 93 / Olympic: 82

Warranty Coverage

Both brands offer lifetime limited warranties on select paints. However, Sherwin Williams provides stronger support through their professional warranty programs, including the Lifetime Limited Warranty on Duration. Olympic warranties are generally available only on their top-tier products and are more limited in scope.

Score: Sherwin Williams: 93 / Olympic: 85

Conclusion

After reviewing current product lines, Sherwin Williams continues to outperform Olympic Paint across nearly every category in 2025. From superior moisture resistance and broader low-VOC options to better self-priming and warranty support, Sherwin Williams remains the preferred choice for most New England homeowners.

While Olympic may offer cost savings up front, Sherwin Williams’ performance often results in fewer coats, better weather protection, and longer-lasting results saving you time and money in the long run.

See Sherwin Williams in Action

Want to see the power of Sherwin Williams paint on a real New England home? Check out our recent exterior painting project in Milford, MA, where we used Sherwin Williams Latitude Flat Extra White for the siding and Tricorn Black Satin for the shutters.

This stunning Garrison Colonial was transformed with expert prep work, rot repair, and a bold-yet-classic color combination—proof that choosing the right paint brand and contractor makes all the difference.

Looking to Paint Your Home in New England?

At United Home Experts, we’ve helped thousands of homeowners throughout Massachusetts, Rhode Island, Connecticut, New Hampshire, and Maine achieve beautiful, lasting results. If you’re considering an exterior paint project and want trusted guidance on product selection and application, schedule a free, no-pressure estimate with our team today.